Payroll employment fell 125,000 in June, as temporary Census jobs were eliminated.
Private payroll employment rose
83,000—weak, although better than May. The details of the report point to a
slowing economy.
- June payrolls fell 125,000, as Census jobs dropped by 225,000. Private
payrolls rose 83,000, up from 33,000 in May. The unemployment rate dropped to
9.5%, from 9.7%.
Good News:
- Private services job creation accelerated to 91,000, from 20,000 in May.
Bad News:
- Manufacturing jobs rose only 9,000, down from 32,000 in May.
- The workweek fell and hourly earnings fell, driving consumer incomes lower.
- Unemployment fell only because the labor force dropped by 652,000, as some
people gave up looking for work.
- The report is the latest in a series of data releases showing that the
economy has lost momentum, though that does not mean the economy will "double
dip."
- We think that GDP growth in the second quarter was still near 4%, but that
is in the past now. We are looking for growth only in the 2.0–2.5% region during
the second half of the year.
The June jobs report could have been worse—but it wasn't good. Private
payrolls rose 83,000, which is less than consensus expectations. But after the
bleak consumer confidence and ADP employment reports earlier in the week, the
markets had probably feared worse. The 83,000 increase is better than May's
revised 33,000 gain, but is still weak. And the details of the report were
discouraging—the workweek shrank, hourly earnings fell, and the unemployment
rate dropped only because the labor force fell even more than employment.
In the details, manufacturing added 9,000 jobs, the smallest increase this
year. Durable goods added 13,000, while nondurables fell 4,000. The
manufacturing workweek fell back to 40.0 hours, from 40.5 hours in May.
Production-worker hours fell 1.0%, reversing May's gain, and pointing to a
decrease in manufacturing output during June. Manufacturing remains the
strongest part of the economy, but even it is losing momentum as the impetus
from the turn in the inventory cycle begins to wane.
Construction continued to shrink, shedding 22,000 jobs, following a 30,000
loss in May. Residential categories lost 6,000 jobs, while nonresidential lost
17,000. Heavy and civil engineering added 1,000, perhaps propped up by stimulus
spending. The nonresidential losses suggest that private nonresidential
construction spending has still not reached bottom, and residential construction
employment is being hurt by the renewed decline in housing starts after the
expiry of the homebuyers' tax credit.
In the private services sector, 91,000 jobs were added in June, after a
20,000 increase in May. Of these, 21,000 jobs were temporary. Leisure and
hospitality added 37,000 jobs, after an unusually weak May (when it lost 8,000
jobs), with a big upswing in amusements and gambling. Retail trade, information,
and financial services all lost jobs, as in May, while the health sector had
another small increase of just 9,000 jobs.
The government shed 208,000 jobs, as 225,000 temporary Census workers were
let go. Overall federal employment fell 198,000, as non-Census employment rose.
State and local governments shed 10,000 jobs, as budget cuts continued to take
their toll; further severe cuts are in prospect here, given the increasing
pressure on state and local budgets as federal stimulus support is phased out.
With private employment rising but the workweek down, total hours-worked in
the private sector fell 0.2%, the first drop since a weather-distorted decrease
in February. That leaves hours up 3.3% at an annual rate in the second quarter,
faster that the 2.4% increase in the first. That suggests an acceleration in
second-quarter GDP growth from the 2.7% rate in the first quarter, but means
little momentum entering the third quarter. Average hourly earnings fell 0.1%,
further depressing income growth when combined with reduced hours.
The unemployment rate fell to 9.5%, from 9.7% in May. Household employment
dropped by 301,000, but the labor force fell even more, by 652,000, suggesting
that some people gave up looking for work. This is consistent with the story
told by the Conference Board consumer confidence survey, which showed that
labor-market perceptions had deteriorated. The labor-force decline may have been
exaggerated by the loss of Census workers, some of whom (especially retired
workers) may no longer be seeking work. It is also possible that some of those
who have lost unemployment benefits due to the expiry of the extended programs
at the beginning of June may now be declaring themselves to be out of the labor
force.
The most comprehensive measure of underemployment (U-6)—which includes
workers who would like a job but are not currently looking, plus those working
part time who would rather work full time—also fell in June, but only by
one-tenth of a point, from 16.6% to 16.5%. The numbers of unemployed for 27
weeks and longer edged down by 12,000, but still represented a near-record high
45.5% of all unemployment.
This report is the latest in a series of weak economic indicators. We do not
believe that the U.S. economy is heading for a double-dip recession, but the
data are telling us that we entered the second quarter with plenty of momentum
and exited it with very little. Stimulus programs for housing and consumer
spending have expired, the inventory-cycle boost is fading, and the Eurozone
sovereign debt crisis has tightened conditions in financial markets. We think
that growth in the second quarter was still near 4%, but that is in the past
now. We are looking for growth only in the 2.0–2.5% region during the second
half of the year.